Articles  >  Know  >  Great Refusal Theory

Great Refusal Theory

The date of October 8th, 1906 remained in history as a symbol of the great refusal from well-deserved honours. Finnish writer Arvid Järnefelt receives a letter from Leo Tolstoy, he is eagerly tearing the envelope, looking at writing of Russian novelist “Please try to make it so that I would not be awarded with the Nobel Prize. If it was meant to happen, then it would be very unpleasant for me to refuse from it.”

The only reason why the 78-year-old great literary mind declined the award, was a favourite formula of idealists “Money means evil.” In a letter to a colleague from Finland Leo Tolstoy explained that money can only bring evil, therefore it is impossible to dispose of such a fortune without forfeiting honour. Järnefelt complied with request of the author of War and Peace, and the Prize went to the Italian poet Giosuè Carducci.

Another writer who rejected the award for altruistic reasons was Jean-Paul Sartre. In 1964 the award founders of the defined his work as “rich in ideas and filled with the spirit of freedom and the quest for truth”. The famous modernist, whose characters are poisoned and nauseous with drab existence and are stumbling upon a wall of non-understanding, acted in accordance with his principles. Independence, as “the most important concept of philosophy”, did not allow Sartre to accept the award. What kind of independence is it about? It is explained in the essay Why I refused the Prize: My sympathies for the Venezuelan revolutionists commit only myself, while if Jean-Paul Sartre the Nobel laureate champions the Venezuelan resistance, he also commits the entire Nobel Prize as an institution. This is not the first rejection of prize by Sartre: in 1945 high-rank friends suggested the philosopher to have the Legion of Honour medal, but the modernist did not accept this gift. And then even declared that literature functioned ultimately as a bourgeois substitute for real commitment in the world, which means that there is nothing left for him in novelism.

For ideological reasons Grigori Perelman did not accept a cash prize, and it happened twice: in 2006 he declined the Fields Medal which is analogue of the Nobel Prize for mathematicians, and in 2010 he turned down prize of the Clay Mathematics Institute for solving the Poincaré conjecture, over which scientists had fought for more than a hundred years. The reasons remain unknown, however, there is a paradox: Perelman claims he does not need any money (by the way, the premium reached a million dollars!), yet he dwells on the outskirts of St. Petersburg in a small room having table, chairs, beds and cockroaches. According to another version, the mathematician has a keen sense of justice and believes that his contribution to science is equivalent to one of the American mathematician Richard Hamilton, and that reward shall find those who deserve it.

However, for some of prominent minds rejection of international recognition was a real tragedy.

“What sort of dirty trick I’ve done, am I a murderer, a villain? I, who made the whole world crying of my homeland’s beauty…”

Boris Pasternak wrote those lines about persecution by the national authorities. Rumours that Pasternak nominated for the Nobel Prize spread from 1946 to 1950, but as soon as European journalists wrote about it, critics intensified in his homeland

“I would more likely be afraid this to become truth, than to wish it, despite such award does not necessarily mean a trip there, to the wide open world, nor an exchange of thoughts – but still, I wouldn’t be able to act as usual talking doll on such trip… Such a Babylon capture. “

In 1955 the writer finishes Doctor Zhivago and three years later he was awarded with the Nobel Prize. Then, as usual, followed threats of persecution and death penalty. Words of encouragement in the Western press seem a drop in the ocean of threats and humiliation, which Pasternak suffered in the Soviet Union. However, Boris Leonidovich did not lose faith till his muse and love Olga Ivinskaya, inspiration for the character of Lara in Doctor Zhivago, was dismissed from workplace. One grey October morning Pasternak goes to the telegraph and sends telegram to Stockholm with a decline of the Prize, and another telegram to the Party’s Central Committee “Restore Ivinskaya at her workplace, I declined the award”.

The authorities imposed similar circumstances on another writer of genius whose talent the Nobel Committee described as a “for the ethical force with which he has pursued the indispensable traditions of Russian literature.” Alexander Solzhenitsyn was not able to obtain the Prize from Sweden during 1970-1974 years, in fear of prohibition to come back to the Soviet Union. Nevertheless, the author of the cult novel The Gulag Archipelago was announced as a dissident and eventually he was deprived of citizenship. As they say, there would be a blessing in disguise - thus Solzhenitsyn was finally able to receive the cash reward. However, Solzhenitsyn turned down another award: in 1998 Boris Yeltsin signed a decree awarding him with the Order of St. Andrew the Apostle, to which the novelist commented “I cannot accept an award from the supreme authority which brought Russia to its current disastrous state… Maybe after a long time, when Russia finds its way out of its troubles, my sons will be able to receive it in my place. “

Finally, more recently in 2004 the Nobel Prize was awarded to an Austrian playwright and novelist Elfriede Jelinek.

She did not come to the ceremony on purpose, as considered such an honour to be undeserved. However, she did not snub the remuneration.

For many geniuses it is typical to perceive their gift as a game, rules of which either accepted, or rejected. The formal reasons for refusal from awards vary widely from ideological ones to blackmailing of relatives, nevertheless, the essence remains the same that is a reluctance to become dependent on the conditions imposed.

It will be interesting:
Yummy fingers: What awaits you behind scenes of the world best kitchens
Can you remember the most unusual dish that you had ever a chance to try? You decide what kind of food it was: something exotic; those insects that we can hardly imagine as an ingredient; strange drink with a bitter taste; an unexpected combination of bitter and sour... Everyone has his or her own unforgettable experience in this regard. Today we would like to tell our readers about unusual and prominent chefs of the world, and even without reference to their era. Dedicated to admirers of history.
I came, I saw, I built. Masterpieces of Giovanni Lorenzo Bernini
Sometimes it happens that you look at a postcard with a picture of a city and instantly realize that this is Kyiv, or Moscow, or Rome or your native village. And it isn’t courtesy of your geography teacher but back-breaking efforts of artisans with whose hands commonly familiar architecture masterpieces were created. Today we recall Italian conqueror of marble Gian Lorenzo Bernini.
Know Ukrainians: Serge Lifar
In the childhood a famous Frenchman from Ukraine was a blue-eyed dreamer. Once all his dreams came true. Whatever he wanted, everything was easy, as if luck was following him. HBe was singing in the choir, he made his best at artistic talent - and, finally, he succeeded in ballet.
Art of Patrick Cabral: paper as a symbol of fragility of our world
Independent artist originally from the Philippines, Patrick Cabral conquers the world with his unusual artwork. His creations are an innovation that combines the age-old traditions of calligraphy and cutting-edge 3D technologies. His art is a way to change the world for the better, both through aesthetics and through the fulfillment of a social mission.
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW: Peter Høeg: "There was no bottom, only eternal falling"
Peter Høeg is Danish writer and philosopher. Sometimes he is called as anchoret because he comes to society events quite rarely, only to represent his new books. The indoor life led to numerous legends that penetrate the image of Peter Høeg on his motherland. In this interview Peter Høeg told OUTLOOK how new novels are created, what hides behind the evident asceticism, and shared his view of life and person.
Packed and Ready: Oleg Borschevskiy
Oleg Borschevskiy is a famous film director, screenwriter and music video director. Among his works, there are music videos for such stars as Potap and Nastia, music bands NeAngely, Boombox, NIKITA, singers Maria Burmaka, Tonia Matvienko and many others. In a nice conversation, he recalled the most interesting places on the world map, which he visited and shared his personal disappointments.
Pablo Picasso: Poet for his era
About Picasso as a distinctive artist, graphic artist and sculptor, we know to some extent everything. Meanwhile, his other incarnations are pushed into the background. Ilya Ehrenburgh once very concisely described Pablo Picasso’s relations with his era: “20th century found in him its own dynamite expert, its own philosopher and its own poet”.
Where stars are “set glowing”
There’s hardly anything that compares to bright-starred sky and silence. It is the stars that OUTLOOK want to tell you about or more precisely about the places with the best view on them. In Europe it is recommended to go stargazing not to some place but to… Slovenia. Point is, this small country is one of the cleanest in the world and consequently isn’t that polluted with smog.
Know Ukrainians: Continuous music of Lubomyr Melnyk
The music as long as the eternity or, in other words, Continuous music is the genre which causes loud arguments in professional circles. Lubomyr Melnyk, Canadian composer of Ukrainian origination sees in his ‘child’ Continuous music continuation of classic traditions. Which rules his scripts follow will OUTLOOK tell in the following material of the rubrics ‘Look at us!’
VIDEO: Majestic heritage of Uzbekistan
Thanks to the Embassy of Uzbekistan in Ukraine and personally Ambassador extraordinary and Plenipotentiary Alisher Abdualiev OUTLOOK was lucky enough to visit this hospitable country. And today we will tell about a unique place - the Mausoleum of the prominent military leader and political figure of Amir Temur.
Don’t break the tongue: The hardest languages in the world
It is said, the easier it is, the better we feel, however, is it always like that? We know that not all the nations follow this principle. Outlook has found out the strangest, toughest and hard in articulation international languages and would like to share it with the readers.
The magnificent world of land-art: Patrick Dougherti
Land-art is not simply the landscape design but also the whole direction in art which in thee 21-st century considered one of the most important when only lazy people do not speak about the ‘green technologies’ and environment. The names of stars of such an activity have sturdily come into the speech of the tutors, critics, and connoisseurs, especially they outline Patrick Dougherti with his unbelievable works.
Sculpture of the Vatican: history and philosophy
"A small territory with a great mission" is the motto under which on February 11, 1929 Lateran Treaty between the Kingdom of Italy and the Holy See recognized Vatican as a sovereign territory. It was an agreement which opened doors for curious patrons who for centuries had been trading gossip about "What is kept inside Vatican castles?". Evil tongues grumbled that the walled enclave protected magic books of how to seize the world, the castle’s cellars hide torture chambers for sinners, and after liturgies alchemists are busy inventing the Philosopher's Stone. But when museums welcomed visitors, both guests and the Romans gasped with delight. Collectors estimated that the cost of all the works of art featured by almost the smallest country in the world, is 150 times more than the world's GDP.
Know Ukrainians: Michael Yarymovych
Behind the famous landing of Neil Armstrong and his team of the Moon in 1969 there wasn’t just an abstract triumph of the power of human brain but also a large group of highly-skilled engineers solving complicated tasks. Among them there was one specially standing out with his bold and unusual approach – a native of Ukraine Michael Yarymovych, one of supervisors of the “Moon program”. It is about him that we proudly tell about today within the framework of our column Ours Make the Grade.
Flowers in Ukrainian Style. Kateryna Bilokur
In every art there are formats and rules – once in “mainstream” an Artist won’t have to starve. Even more so in totalitarian times when every sphere of people’s life is controlled and affected and selfhood has to be forgotten as such. It is probably in the face of a system natural talents emerge for their work to become immortal. Today Outlook recalls one of them, artist Kateryna Bilokur.
A jewelry approach to perfection
Behind the window sad eyes of old man peered at Petrograd engulfed by revolutionary fire. This fire spread on his life's work: a proud four-story building was invaded by noisy commissioners and sailors, whose presence seemed a cruel joke after regular customers. Workshop owner Carl Gustavovich Fabergé, apparently, noticed in this chaos approaching decay of his career. However, he could have a secret gleam of hope for another life of his heritage. If only he knew that it would come true, maestro would hardly have lost his spiritual strength...
Underground Brilliance of the Empire: Budapest Metro
After having spent merely an hour for a flight from Kiev, I suddenly realized I reached the city where continental Europe’s oldest subway is situated. And things that Budapest underground is famous for are not limited to this. OUTLOOK sets on a trip around metropolitan of one of the world’s most beautiful cities. Want to go down?
Know Ukrainians: Sergei Polinin
On the 26-th of October it will be going a desirable premier of documental and biographic movie ‘Dancer’ on the price of success paid by the artist of ballet Serhii Polunin. Being originated from Kherson, he accidentally appeared in the Royal Theater in London where he became an overnight success but then went off the grid to get even more love of the spectators. Today OUTLOOK continues the cycle of materials about successful Ukrainians.
Not only a tower is a symbol. The best works of Gustav Eiffel
The word is, Guy de Maupassant hated Eiffel Tower. The famous writer believed that it was uglifying the face of Paris without benefiting the city. Nevertheless, he could be often seen in a cozy cafe on the top of the construction. In such cases the author of “Bel Ami” used to say that “it was the only way the damned tower dropped out of his sight…”
Swedish Loner Ingmar Bergman
On July 14, 1918 in a Swedish town called Uppsala a man was born to create over 50 movies and direct several dozens of plays that raised the ante in art to an almost inaccessible level. Even today while watching his film created as much as half a century ago you realize that there is nothing they’ve lost – it’s more like they’ve gained.
Outlook facebook page